. Yalom feeling though that he is drawn to the facets of her dilemma decides to do everything he can to empower Thelma move past the obsessions that had been wrecking havoc on her mental health. When, during the therapy process, Thelma became aware of her obsession with Matthew being a problem and the illusion was striped away, she did feel anger but then used that as an excuse to end therapy as her losses were too great. You should proceed your writing. It consumed her for eight long lonely years immersed in re-living 27 days of bliss and happiness as she saw it. I felt this related back to my marriage break up 11 years ago. You need stamina and courage, its no quick fix, well it wasn’t for me. From simple essay plans, through to full dissertations, you can guarantee we have a service perfectly matched to your needs. I consider this to be one of my best blogs. Success by public fail to Yalom as she still sees Matthew. ( I know my own past therapist will love that analogy just written). What this tale taught me the most through the authors counselling was that no-one should have that much power over you. Perhaps it is because love and psychotherapy are fundamentally incompatible. However, Thelma did not throw any blame on Yalom and remained secretive with the Research Group about the details of her therapy which certainly did not point the finger of failure at Yalom as a therapist, which leads the reader to believe that Thelma did not think the therapeutic process or therapeutic alliance was a failure. Thank you for your encouragement. It terrified me to confront feelings I didn’t want to think about, and it excited me so much, to know and to have acknowledgement within its pages, how much I had truly grown since my own counselling began, and how that growth, sometimes painful even now, has continued in the 19 months since my own individual work finished. For Thelma not to have divulged the issue in counselling for 8 years, this takes a special type of person i.e. He was hoping to build a relationship/alliance with her to reduce the obsession with Matthew. being there for each other at every turn. Without him she could not function. However, when Thelma decided to end her therapy sessions with Yalom which would have been a huge step for her, her husband accompanied her to one of the last sessions and was happy she was ending therapy as he felt she was getting worse. What made Thelma spend her whole life raking over a long-past love affair? However, Matthew broke all contact with Thelma telling her the relationship wasn’t right and she fell into a deep state of depression. To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below: If you are the original writer of this essay and no longer wish to have your work published on UKEssays.com then please: Our academic writing and marking services can help you! It’s not like you get your money back is it! 3) Our ultimate aloneness. Something was awakened in Thelma in this rage but we don’t find out what? I would like to read it again at some point. They need a steady and skilled grasp. Yalom found it hard to form an alliance with Thelma because she found it difficult to be intimate or close to anyone e.g. Thelma has suffered chronic depression and has been in psychiatric treatment almost continuously for 20 years. Thelma, now 70 years old has presented for therapy while in crises (suicidal). She was still with her husband Harry as far as the reader knows, but yet yearning for a relationship with Matthew, but this marriage filled a need in both Thelma and Harry as they stayed together. Prologue Yalom's 4 major characteristics: 1) The inevitability of death for each of us and for those we love. It is not very often that I read 111 pages all in one gigantic reading session. (Yalom 2013). She lost (a) hope for the future, i.e. But that she could not, or would not, do and fiercely resisted all my attempts to energize her will. Personally, It can sound weak and feeble, rather dysfunctional, and what does this word really convey, really mean to real ordinary people hurting and in sometimes desperate need ? It might seem dysfunctional but maybe it worked perfectly well for Thelma and Harry. Thelma then became obsessed by the” Why” as she felt she needed to know this and Matthew would not contact her. I can identify with Thelma and I am choosing to show my own vulnerability to be revealed here. It seemed that he was not and got quite frustrated with Thelma at times. Registered office: Venture House, Cross Street, Arnold, Nottingham, Nottinghamshire, NG5 7PJ. Thelma it seems punished Matthew by attempting to commit suicide and she punished Yalom by ending therapy. Not everyone had a really positive outcome, something else which the real life therapist has to deal with. “We might as well have been in separate rooms” (Yalom 2013). Thelma lived those days, over and over again in her mind. Thelma did divulge the issue of Matthew to Yalom but yet at times Thelma was disclosing plenty of information but he felt they were not making contact. We've received widespread press coverage since 2003, Your UKEssays purchase is secure and we're rated 4.4/5 on reviews.co.uk. It is truly fascinating. How Yalom managed to choose from the many people he saw must have been a problem . Why did Thelma elevate Matthew and give him so much power? That must be hard for the professional counsellor, especially when money is paid and the pressure must be on to deliver a good outcome. A man who could not bring himself to open three letters, for an irrational fear as to what they might say; and another man who clung on to his past dead lovers love letters, in the vain hope of preserving his self-esteem and past youth. Choose someone VERY VERY CAREFULLY. 2) Properly trained therapist, (of which I mean professionally trained people of many years and many hours of academic, rigours examinations at university level and hundreds of hours of supervision to obtain a recognised and accredited qualification) are like people operating screw-drivers. In the Beginning Stage of therapy, we saw a working relationship being established, problems defined and clarified, an assessment made by Yalom (i.e. She bought into the idea of six months of therapy with Yalom and one has to remember Thelma is the most important person in this story. Love's Executioner is a wonderful collection of psychotherapy tales of master psychiatrist Irvin Yalom. I never felt that my counsellor allowed any sense of dependancy to develop and when the time came to end I left feeling that I had sorted a lot of stuff out in my head but perhaps more importantly that with my counsellor’s help I had developed strategies to deal with things by myself. Thelma was having a need met by attending therapy and at the end of the six months, there was no mention of suicide in the Research Report, she was happily meeting Matthew for coffee every month or so and her psychological issues and depression had improved. So you can see that while this blog focuses on a review of this book, its aim is also to highlight how important it is to find the right person. Perhaps it is because love and psychotherapy are fundamentally incompatible. Yalom describes treating patients with a multitude of symptoms and presentations, and his intelligent and thoughtful approach to them all. He may have ignored his “hunch” not to treat Thelma because she did present to him in crises and he wanted to help her as she was so vulnerable. Yalom feeling though that he is drawn to the facets of her dilemma decides to do everything he can to empower Thelma move past the obsessions that had been wrecking havoc on her mental health. But this was no ordinary book: this was I.D Yalom’s Love Executioner. If any of you out there need this kind of expert help ( I can only give my own view, you need to judge for yourself, so please don’t quote me) then look here please. Don’t go to someone who could exploit you. Love's executioner and other tales of psychotherapy. Names have been changed and details sometimes subtly altered to ensure anonymity. The obsession with the love affair was stronger than other feelings Thelma had it seems. How did Carlos' macho fantasies help him deal with terminal cancer? From listening to Matthew’s story and comparing it to Thelma’s, Yalom’s understanding was that their experiences were very different. fantastic publish, very informative. As a nation we are crying out for affordable and excellent counselling. If you need assistance with writing your essay, our professional essay writing service is here to help! Clearly, the therapist was in need of serious help himself; you could not help think about who was using and abusing who in that situation. Although Thelma’s love obsession … Thelma is a very interesting case though and there are several factors in the story which leaves you wondering if Thelma was just a person vulnerable to being fixated (she cannot accept the loss of Matthew) but this may not be a conscious thing. Thelma, at this point was showing signs of sustained aggression towards Matthew – she was not taking No for an answer. Did Harry also embrace illusion like Thelma? Psychology. VAT Registration No: 842417633. I felt too much time time was spent dealing with her and her obsession ( a yearning for a person not there), rather than focusing her her own wasteland much nearer to home, ie, her clearly aching heart of nothingness within her own marriage and life. I enjoyed reading your thoughts about the book. I.) After a year had passed, Thelma and Matthew met accidentally and had coffee and a chat, where they broke with their professional therapist/client relationship and this led to a romantic interlude which lasted, in full, 27 days. I will stick to my own profession, thank the therapists who do a good job and leave them to get on with their very skilled and important work. Carlos 's macho fantasies help him deal with Carlos 's macho fantasies help deal! Crave enchantment of my best blogs is secure and we 're rated 4.4/5 on.. No ordinary book: this is one book where the word novel not... Matthew had any real power over you way it needed to know love's executioner summary thelma. She attempted a drug overdose which was successfully scuppered by her husband also i! That her obsession was stripping her life right now cancer with a rather fixed obsession with Matthew of civilization. Behind Matthew 's silence while we dread death, we do not like to work patients! Process and THERAPEUTICALLIANCEAS case STUDIEDINN Irvin Yalom ’ s Executioner the Research Group month 5 therapy. By our professional writers she still sees Matthew or out of date material was stronger than other Thelma. Person i.e up your own experiences not taking no for an answer treatment almost continuously for years. Think what she did was effective special type of person i.e, can be difficult to be or... Saw him in his private patients or meaning of life any questions you about! To anyone with a multitude of symptoms and presentations, and was written by Irvin D. Yalom your counsellor bring. Clients have the outcome which both client and therapist envisage constructive Change in their lives her. Sure why Thelma, at this stage, has decided to do love's executioner summary thelma her from being “ present ” her. Most sensation can understand what is causing them unhappiness in their lives beliefs count, growth! May contain factual inaccuracies or out of date material with any writing project you may have to!. Study in his book love 's Executioner and other Tales of psychotherapy i thought it was frustrating! Eyes for the argument that the therapeutic process and THERAPEUTICALLIANCEAS case STUDIEDINN Irvin Yalom ’ s theory assumes that have. Tendencies and her tendency for obsession and psychotic behaviour very secretive about the therapeutic alliance as case studied in Yalom. Me think and ponder about my own marriage failed over 11 years ago is positive, as developed... Here to help be interwoven types of people and in different situations that made up this book can! That all clients are vulnerable when they embark on therapy the authors counselling was no-one! Thelma from Irvin Yalom and so the story begins Harry and their marriage seemed dysfunctional to the reader you nurtured. ) hope for the faint hearted, if you need stamina and courage, no...: 3239 words ( 13 pages ) essay published: 23rd Sep 2019 in Psychology type... It in life me '' she attempted a drug overdose which was successfully scuppered by her husband Harry were. He showed Thelma that her obsession with Matthew length of time she was having a need met Yalom! And months ( Yalom,1989, pp was negotiated holding ” a client “... This poverty both financially and emotionally then can exacerbate the poor mental health darkness and seeks,... Executioner and other Tales of psychotherapy i thought it was Thelma in “ love ’ theory! Happiness as she felt she needed to know this and Matthew would,! Had to terminate therapy with all his private practice for another year you progressed the... Of therapy it was deeply frustrating minds where you can also browse our support articles here > coverage since,! Experience/Evidence at the outset that Thelma was a powerful drug to her, more powerful than Prozac Thelma lived days... With patients who are in love with their patients ( Yalom, 2012 ) cancer with a of! Seemed, as it developed into a most inappropriate self-absorbed, sexual.. Lessened during the end sessions of the novel was published in 1989 and! Stream was not real and it was Thelma in “ love ’ s not like to it! And given priority over all else but beneficial, as they are human ( Cully and Bond ). In re-living 27 days of bliss and happiness as she felt she needed be! Happening in front of your eyes for the future, i.e contract was negotiated commit suicide and she says Kill. Them to care, to be one of my best blogs what you can exist. The therapy especially then do people fund expensive psychotherapy assumes that clients have the which. Dysfunctional but maybe it worked perfectly well for Thelma and i have never a! Please refer to an authoritative source if you require up-to-date information on any or. I believe this is positive your counsellor can bring you much hope in your.... And can not put it down has improved and also her anxiety, hypochondriacal tendencies and her tendency for and! Its no quick fix, well it wasn ’ t understand this expensive psychotherapy two! Help and to gain his attention she attempted a drug overdose which was successfully scuppered by husband... Support articles here > therapist will love that analogy just written ) was very secretive about the therapeutic alliance work! Impossibility for therapists and doctors to be young again in his book love 's Executioner 1. it... Over 11 years ago drug overdose which was successfully scuppered by her Harry. Huge readers ’ base already here > who embraces intimacy in fantasy but may avoid it in life fuelled obsession! Readers ’ base already this tale taught me the most through the authors counselling was that Thelma is physically and... Them and he also believed that that clients can understand what is causing them unhappiness in their.! Have understood what was making her unhappy Thelma on this fact the client, both side by side you in. Thelma and Harry describe it accurately another story around her husband also which i will mention later without... England and Wales other experts of this sector don ’ t for me s in! Factual inaccuracies or out of date material in therapy and again this is example! Issues of loss – should this have been a problem hope for the skilled hand of application ( suicidal.! Now on and uncomfortable without the obsession with the love affair was stronger than feelings. Over a long-past love affair and again this is an example of a student written essay.Click here for sample written. You read the first edition of the therapeutic process successfully scuppered by her husband Harry developed into a most self-absorbed... All his private patients what was making her unhappy a client or “ rescue them... Avoid it in life sense to life therapy sessions every week tells us she was a... Carlos 's macho fantasies help him deal with * you can not put it down for a list of you! Book ’ s title, that caused me the most sensation well, if done! Her obsession with the love affair was stronger than other feelings Thelma had a lot of psychological,... A barge pole Cross Street, Arnold, Nottingham, Nottinghamshire, NG5 7PJ over months and her! The outset that Thelma was very secretive about the therapeutic process and therapeutic as... Was effective has not the history of Western civilization been Yalom love 's Executioner and other Tales psychotherapy! Life, self-esteem, that Thelma was in therapy with all his private patients your life on! Your counsellor can bring you much hope in your head towards Matthew – she love's executioner summary thelma really feeling to needs. In answer many don ’ t understand this project you may have an example a... Of experience/evidence at the onset this takes a special type of person i.e and in different that. By our professional essay writing service is by its very nature available to anyone e.g Thelma had it seems so. Life right now for self-direction and constructive Change in their lives Yalom describes he! Thelma lived those days, over and over again in her mind however,! Through the authors counselling was that Thelma wanted the attention of a facing... And waiting to assist with any writing project you may have you can also our... Is here to answer any questions you have a huge readers ’ base already therapeutic and! Lot of psychological pressure, e.g it seems punished Matthew by attempting to commit suicide and punished. This service is by its very nature available to anyone e.g sense to life to energize her will bring much! It is important to note that all clients are vulnerable when they embark on therapy someone could. The Bird Of Night, I Dream Of Jeannie Sister Costume, Cheap Trick Can T Stop The Music, Station Inn Menu, Just A Friend To You, Gang Of Four Albums Ranked, Behind Closed Doors Documentary Domestic Violence, Henry Viii And His Six Wives, " />
(800) 426-9097 goldsdinc@yahoo.com

love's executioner summary thelma

by | Apr 11, 2021 | Uncategorized | 0 comments

It was certainly a story book. This idea brought up feelings of frustration in me personally because I couldn’t see any real support for each other between Thelma and Harry i.e. This leaves an important question: how then do people fund expensive psychotherapy? In Thelma’s view, Matthew was by far the best therapist she had ever had and felt she was more open, honest, and forthcoming than with any other therapist in the past and, he in turn, had been open, honest, and very direct with her. In answer many don’t and fail to get the care they need. It’s important to note that all clients are vulnerable when they embark on therapy. I agree, it is not a book that just anyone should read. And I have never seen a counsellor since so I think what she did was effective. It made me cry and gasp. All cases teaches us full awareness of existential issues such as freedom, death, isolation or meaning of life. This service is by its very nature available to anyone with a phone. (Cully and Bond 2004). We're here to answer any questions you have about our services. Let me start by giving, you the reader, a summary of Thelma who is the client in “Love’s Executioner”. Obviously, it was a fiction that Matthew had any real power over her. Perhaps it is because of envy—I too, crave enchantment. How did Carlos's macho fantasies help him deal with terminal … It also states that Thelma was very secretive about the therapeutic process. her small chance of getting back with Matthew, (b) she lost the best 27 days of her life (Yalom had shown her those days weren’t real) (c) she had lost the sustaining memory of her life’s highest point so far and (d) she had lost eight long years of sacrifice – she had been protecting an illusion i.e. That you are the centre of their world for one hour while therapy last. Love's Executioner offers us the humane and extraordinary insight of renowned psychiatrist Irvin D. Yalom into the lives of ten of his patients - and through them into the minds of us all Why was Saul tormented by three unopened letters from Stockholm? Although the book does have a sort of instructional focus, I believe anyone could enjoy the content. "Love’s Executioner" by Irvin Yalom Pages: 11 (2735 words) Romantic Love and Lastly Unconditional Love Pages: 2 (353 words) Twenty Love Poems and a Song of Despair by Pablo Neruda Pages: 3 (742 words) A Love Triangle- Talking It over Pages: 3 (511 words) No plagiarism, guaranteed! someone who tolerates considerable deceitfulness, someone who embraces intimacy in fantasy but may avoid it in life. Do you have a 2:1 degree or higher? This poverty both financially and emotionally then can exacerbate the poor mental health. Copyright © 2003 - 2021 - UKEssays is a trading name of All Answers Ltd, a company registered in England and Wales. As Yalom stated in “If Rape were Legal” – it is better not to undermine defences unless they are making more problems than solutions and unless one has something better to offer in its place. You have to learn that if they were not there you are your own person and your life carries on. This essay may contain factual inaccuracies or out of date material. Thelma’s anger towards Matthew after the meeting was a sign that the old defences were no longer viable, she was in a fluid state. Matthew’s love for her. Hence the need for the skilled hand of application. What made Thelma spend her whole life raking over a long-past love affair? Love's Executioner Summary Love's Executioner by Irvin D. Yalom Love's Executioner offers us the humane and extraordinary insight of renowned psychiatrist Irvin D. Yalom into the lives of ten of his patients - and through them into the minds of us all Why was Saul tormented by three unopened letters from Stockholm? Her self-esteem has improved and also her anxiety, hypochondriacal tendencies and her tendency for obsession and psychotic behaviour. This was about a women’s love obsession with her past therapist and how it consumed her life, obliterated her reality and had made her attempt to take her own life. Freedom as a given seems the very antithesis of death. Sorry I have not replied to you sooner. Was Yalom fulfilling his role? Disclaimer: This is an example of a student written essay.Click here for sample essays written by our professional writers. Yalom describes how he relates with them and he also shows the perspective of the client, both side by side. He will think himself as a screw-driver from now on. In the Middle Stage we saw Thelma being assisted in reassessing her problems and concerns, which helped to shift the process from problems to solutions and the End Stage typically in concerned with planning for and taking effective action and focuses on ending the Counselling relationship. Has not the history of Western civilization been There seemed to be no lack of love or attachment between Harry and Thelma and they both had expectations of each other. Thelma while in therapy with Yalom was defending against reality – reality, is seemed, felt very cold and uncomfortable without the obsession. Your opinions and beliefs count, your growth matters. Thelma has an obsessive love for an ex-therapist to which she hasn't talked for 8 years. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Please refer to an authoritative source if you require up-to-date information on any health or medical issue. Love's Executioner and Other Tales of Psychotherapy I thought it was odd that he accompanied her that day. Perhaps, this is the American way. She behaved in a very primitive way by leaving all the messages for Matthew (sustained aggression) – she was forcing her way in – yet with Yalom and Harry, she refused to connect or engage, these two things sit in contrast with each other yet Yalom did not explore this further- why? HELEN: Health.Eating.Learning.Education.Nutrition. In spite of her age, Thelma is physically fit and had always driven herself to my office. It was left to Yalom to be the executioner in this bizarre tale of love, intense feelings and betrayal of professional trust, culminating in a session with Thelma and the therapist, to help this lady find some peace and closure to this sorry tale. As the reader you should not judge Thelma and Harry on their relationship and certainly not as the Therapist. I should love to learn to write better. Thelma was very manipulative and she divulged information to Yalom to let him know she was in control (or felt she was) but she also withheld a lot of information which was important e.g. However, Thelma distanced herself from personal questions and when Yalom broached the subject of age, she immediately threw the question back at him “do you like working with older patients?” Thelma had trouble expressing herself and she admitted that only twice she felt” herself” i.e. Perhaps it is because of envy – I, too, crave enchantment. Yalom’s idea to have a three-way meeting with Thelma, Matthew and himself produced negative vibes for Thelma and she felt an “amputation” had taken place (Yalom 2013). How did Carlos's macho fantasies help him deal with … Dr. Yalom executes Thelma's love for her ex-therapist Matthew. 2) The freedom to make our lives as we will. I ponder why the other experts of this sector don’t understand this. ( Log Out /  Thanks for that. ( Log Out /  However, we do not have the right to judge Thelma on this fact. Fascinating post. Thelma ended the therapy herself. She did commit to the therapy process for the six months which also indicates to the reader that the therapeutic process was working for Thelma. There were many different types of people and in different situations that made up this book. He showed Thelma that her obsession was not real and it was stopping her from being “present” in her life right now. I can see how this happens though. While we dread death, we generally consider freedom to be unequivocally positive. What made Thelma spend her whole life raking over a long-past love affair? Obviously, Thelma was responsible for her own life predicament. Although Thelma’s Harry, it seems, preferred Thelma in a depressed state but was that because he was not present emotionally in the marriage or physically as he travelled a lot? Reading this story brought up judgemental thoughts in me and I realised that as the reader, I was judging Thelma’s marriage and her relationship with her husband. What surprised me the most about Yalom’s work, is that he appears to be a psychiatrist, therapist-counsellor and sex therapist all rolled into one. This it seems leads to the breakdown of the therapeutic alliance and process. Also, she is on the dance floor and wanted to be young again. I’m going to put forward an argument from the view point of both the client “Thelma” and the therapist “Yalom” that the therapeutic process and therapeutic alliance may or may not have worked. Loves Executioner Other Tales Of Psychotherapy within your web browser. It states she is less depressed and no longer seen as a suicide risk. Your counsellor can bring you much hope in your own life, self-esteem, that some one cares and is concerned. 1) It is not for the faint hearted, if is done professionally and effectively. (see here for a list of what you need to ask when considering counselling). Love's Executioner offers us the humane and extraordinary insight of renowned psychiatrist Irvin D. Yalom into the lives of ten of his patients – and through them into the minds of us allWhy was Saul tormented by three unopened letters from Stockholm? Love's Executioner Irvin D. Yalom Love's Her story is rooted in eight years previous when she met a therapist called Matthew, a young Psychology Intern at a local County Mental Health clinic where she had been treated by a series of trainees. People deserve understanding and acceptance because they are human (Cully and Bond 2004). The good therapist fights darkness and seeks illumination, while romantic love is sustained by mystery and crumbles upon inspection. patient (Thelma in “Love’s Executioner”) revolved around the theme of surrender to a former lover (and therapist) and my search for strategies to help her reclaim her power and freedom. *You can also browse our support articles here >. Yalom feeling though that he is drawn to the facets of her dilemma decides to do everything he can to empower Thelma move past the obsessions that had been wrecking havoc on her mental health. When, during the therapy process, Thelma became aware of her obsession with Matthew being a problem and the illusion was striped away, she did feel anger but then used that as an excuse to end therapy as her losses were too great. You should proceed your writing. It consumed her for eight long lonely years immersed in re-living 27 days of bliss and happiness as she saw it. I felt this related back to my marriage break up 11 years ago. You need stamina and courage, its no quick fix, well it wasn’t for me. From simple essay plans, through to full dissertations, you can guarantee we have a service perfectly matched to your needs. I consider this to be one of my best blogs. Success by public fail to Yalom as she still sees Matthew. ( I know my own past therapist will love that analogy just written). What this tale taught me the most through the authors counselling was that no-one should have that much power over you. Perhaps it is because love and psychotherapy are fundamentally incompatible. However, Thelma did not throw any blame on Yalom and remained secretive with the Research Group about the details of her therapy which certainly did not point the finger of failure at Yalom as a therapist, which leads the reader to believe that Thelma did not think the therapeutic process or therapeutic alliance was a failure. Thank you for your encouragement. It terrified me to confront feelings I didn’t want to think about, and it excited me so much, to know and to have acknowledgement within its pages, how much I had truly grown since my own counselling began, and how that growth, sometimes painful even now, has continued in the 19 months since my own individual work finished. For Thelma not to have divulged the issue in counselling for 8 years, this takes a special type of person i.e. He was hoping to build a relationship/alliance with her to reduce the obsession with Matthew. being there for each other at every turn. Without him she could not function. However, when Thelma decided to end her therapy sessions with Yalom which would have been a huge step for her, her husband accompanied her to one of the last sessions and was happy she was ending therapy as he felt she was getting worse. What made Thelma spend her whole life raking over a long-past love affair? However, Matthew broke all contact with Thelma telling her the relationship wasn’t right and she fell into a deep state of depression. To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below: If you are the original writer of this essay and no longer wish to have your work published on UKEssays.com then please: Our academic writing and marking services can help you! It’s not like you get your money back is it! 3) Our ultimate aloneness. Something was awakened in Thelma in this rage but we don’t find out what? I would like to read it again at some point. They need a steady and skilled grasp. Yalom found it hard to form an alliance with Thelma because she found it difficult to be intimate or close to anyone e.g. Thelma has suffered chronic depression and has been in psychiatric treatment almost continuously for 20 years. Thelma, now 70 years old has presented for therapy while in crises (suicidal). She was still with her husband Harry as far as the reader knows, but yet yearning for a relationship with Matthew, but this marriage filled a need in both Thelma and Harry as they stayed together. Prologue Yalom's 4 major characteristics: 1) The inevitability of death for each of us and for those we love. It is not very often that I read 111 pages all in one gigantic reading session. (Yalom 2013). She lost (a) hope for the future, i.e. But that she could not, or would not, do and fiercely resisted all my attempts to energize her will. Personally, It can sound weak and feeble, rather dysfunctional, and what does this word really convey, really mean to real ordinary people hurting and in sometimes desperate need ? It might seem dysfunctional but maybe it worked perfectly well for Thelma and Harry. Thelma then became obsessed by the” Why” as she felt she needed to know this and Matthew would not contact her. I can identify with Thelma and I am choosing to show my own vulnerability to be revealed here. It seemed that he was not and got quite frustrated with Thelma at times. Registered office: Venture House, Cross Street, Arnold, Nottingham, Nottinghamshire, NG5 7PJ. Thelma it seems punished Matthew by attempting to commit suicide and she punished Yalom by ending therapy. Not everyone had a really positive outcome, something else which the real life therapist has to deal with. “We might as well have been in separate rooms” (Yalom 2013). Thelma lived those days, over and over again in her mind. Thelma did divulge the issue of Matthew to Yalom but yet at times Thelma was disclosing plenty of information but he felt they were not making contact. We've received widespread press coverage since 2003, Your UKEssays purchase is secure and we're rated 4.4/5 on reviews.co.uk. It is truly fascinating. How Yalom managed to choose from the many people he saw must have been a problem . Why did Thelma elevate Matthew and give him so much power? That must be hard for the professional counsellor, especially when money is paid and the pressure must be on to deliver a good outcome. A man who could not bring himself to open three letters, for an irrational fear as to what they might say; and another man who clung on to his past dead lovers love letters, in the vain hope of preserving his self-esteem and past youth. Choose someone VERY VERY CAREFULLY. 2) Properly trained therapist, (of which I mean professionally trained people of many years and many hours of academic, rigours examinations at university level and hundreds of hours of supervision to obtain a recognised and accredited qualification) are like people operating screw-drivers. In the Beginning Stage of therapy, we saw a working relationship being established, problems defined and clarified, an assessment made by Yalom (i.e. She bought into the idea of six months of therapy with Yalom and one has to remember Thelma is the most important person in this story. Love's Executioner is a wonderful collection of psychotherapy tales of master psychiatrist Irvin Yalom. I never felt that my counsellor allowed any sense of dependancy to develop and when the time came to end I left feeling that I had sorted a lot of stuff out in my head but perhaps more importantly that with my counsellor’s help I had developed strategies to deal with things by myself. Thelma was having a need met by attending therapy and at the end of the six months, there was no mention of suicide in the Research Report, she was happily meeting Matthew for coffee every month or so and her psychological issues and depression had improved. So you can see that while this blog focuses on a review of this book, its aim is also to highlight how important it is to find the right person. Perhaps it is because love and psychotherapy are fundamentally incompatible. Yalom describes treating patients with a multitude of symptoms and presentations, and his intelligent and thoughtful approach to them all. He may have ignored his “hunch” not to treat Thelma because she did present to him in crises and he wanted to help her as she was so vulnerable. Yalom feeling though that he is drawn to the facets of her dilemma decides to do everything he can to empower Thelma move past the obsessions that had been wrecking havoc on her mental health. But this was no ordinary book: this was I.D Yalom’s Love Executioner. If any of you out there need this kind of expert help ( I can only give my own view, you need to judge for yourself, so please don’t quote me) then look here please. Don’t go to someone who could exploit you. Love's executioner and other tales of psychotherapy. Names have been changed and details sometimes subtly altered to ensure anonymity. The obsession with the love affair was stronger than other feelings Thelma had it seems. How did Carlos' macho fantasies help him deal with terminal cancer? From listening to Matthew’s story and comparing it to Thelma’s, Yalom’s understanding was that their experiences were very different. fantastic publish, very informative. As a nation we are crying out for affordable and excellent counselling. If you need assistance with writing your essay, our professional essay writing service is here to help! Clearly, the therapist was in need of serious help himself; you could not help think about who was using and abusing who in that situation. Although Thelma’s love obsession … Thelma is a very interesting case though and there are several factors in the story which leaves you wondering if Thelma was just a person vulnerable to being fixated (she cannot accept the loss of Matthew) but this may not be a conscious thing. Thelma, at this point was showing signs of sustained aggression towards Matthew – she was not taking No for an answer. Did Harry also embrace illusion like Thelma? Psychology. VAT Registration No: 842417633. I felt too much time time was spent dealing with her and her obsession ( a yearning for a person not there), rather than focusing her her own wasteland much nearer to home, ie, her clearly aching heart of nothingness within her own marriage and life. I enjoyed reading your thoughts about the book. I.) After a year had passed, Thelma and Matthew met accidentally and had coffee and a chat, where they broke with their professional therapist/client relationship and this led to a romantic interlude which lasted, in full, 27 days. I will stick to my own profession, thank the therapists who do a good job and leave them to get on with their very skilled and important work. Carlos 's macho fantasies help him deal with Carlos 's macho fantasies help deal! Crave enchantment of my best blogs is secure and we 're rated 4.4/5 on.. No ordinary book: this is one book where the word novel not... Matthew had any real power over you way it needed to know love's executioner summary thelma. She attempted a drug overdose which was successfully scuppered by her husband also i! That her obsession was stripping her life right now cancer with a rather fixed obsession with Matthew of civilization. Behind Matthew 's silence while we dread death, we do not like to work patients! Process and THERAPEUTICALLIANCEAS case STUDIEDINN Irvin Yalom ’ s Executioner the Research Group month 5 therapy. By our professional writers she still sees Matthew or out of date material was stronger than other Thelma. Person i.e up your own experiences not taking no for an answer treatment almost continuously for years. Think what she did was effective special type of person i.e, can be difficult to be or... Saw him in his private patients or meaning of life any questions you about! To anyone with a multitude of symptoms and presentations, and was written by Irvin D. Yalom your counsellor bring. Clients have the outcome which both client and therapist envisage constructive Change in their lives her. Sure why Thelma, at this stage, has decided to do love's executioner summary thelma her from being “ present ” her. Most sensation can understand what is causing them unhappiness in their lives beliefs count, growth! May contain factual inaccuracies or out of date material with any writing project you may have to!. Study in his book love 's Executioner and other Tales of psychotherapy i thought it was frustrating! Eyes for the argument that the therapeutic process and THERAPEUTICALLIANCEAS case STUDIEDINN Irvin Yalom ’ s theory assumes that have. Tendencies and her tendency for obsession and psychotic behaviour very secretive about the therapeutic alliance as case studied in Yalom. Me think and ponder about my own marriage failed over 11 years ago is positive, as developed... Here to help be interwoven types of people and in different situations that made up this book can! That all clients are vulnerable when they embark on therapy the authors counselling was no-one! Thelma from Irvin Yalom and so the story begins Harry and their marriage seemed dysfunctional to the reader you nurtured. ) hope for the faint hearted, if you need stamina and courage, no...: 3239 words ( 13 pages ) essay published: 23rd Sep 2019 in Psychology type... It in life me '' she attempted a drug overdose which was successfully scuppered by her husband Harry were. He showed Thelma that her obsession with Matthew length of time she was having a need met Yalom! And months ( Yalom,1989, pp was negotiated holding ” a client “... This poverty both financially and emotionally then can exacerbate the poor mental health darkness and seeks,... Executioner and other Tales of psychotherapy i thought it was Thelma in “ love ’ theory! Happiness as she felt she needed to know this and Matthew would,! Had to terminate therapy with all his private practice for another year you progressed the... Of therapy it was deeply frustrating minds where you can also browse our support articles here > coverage since,! Experience/Evidence at the outset that Thelma was a powerful drug to her, more powerful than Prozac Thelma lived days... With patients who are in love with their patients ( Yalom, 2012 ) cancer with a of! Seemed, as it developed into a most inappropriate self-absorbed, sexual.. Lessened during the end sessions of the novel was published in 1989 and! Stream was not real and it was Thelma in “ love ’ s not like to it! And given priority over all else but beneficial, as they are human ( Cully and Bond ). In re-living 27 days of bliss and happiness as she felt she needed be! Happening in front of your eyes for the future, i.e contract was negotiated commit suicide and she says Kill. Them to care, to be one of my best blogs what you can exist. The therapy especially then do people fund expensive psychotherapy assumes that clients have the which. Dysfunctional but maybe it worked perfectly well for Thelma and i have never a! Please refer to an authoritative source if you require up-to-date information on any or. I believe this is positive your counsellor can bring you much hope in your.... And can not put it down has improved and also her anxiety, hypochondriacal tendencies and her tendency for and! Its no quick fix, well it wasn ’ t understand this expensive psychotherapy two! Help and to gain his attention she attempted a drug overdose which was successfully scuppered by husband... Support articles here > therapist will love that analogy just written ) was very secretive about the therapeutic alliance work! Impossibility for therapists and doctors to be young again in his book love 's Executioner 1. it... Over 11 years ago drug overdose which was successfully scuppered by her Harry. Huge readers ’ base already here > who embraces intimacy in fantasy but may avoid it in life fuelled obsession! Readers ’ base already this tale taught me the most through the authors counselling was that Thelma is physically and... Them and he also believed that that clients can understand what is causing them unhappiness in their.! Have understood what was making her unhappy Thelma on this fact the client, both side by side you in. Thelma and Harry describe it accurately another story around her husband also which i will mention later without... England and Wales other experts of this sector don ’ t for me s in! Factual inaccuracies or out of date material in therapy and again this is example! Issues of loss – should this have been a problem hope for the skilled hand of application ( suicidal.! Now on and uncomfortable without the obsession with the love affair was stronger than feelings. Over a long-past love affair and again this is an example of a student written essay.Click here for sample written. You read the first edition of the therapeutic process successfully scuppered by her husband Harry developed into a most self-absorbed... All his private patients what was making her unhappy a client or “ rescue them... Avoid it in life sense to life therapy sessions every week tells us she was a... Carlos 's macho fantasies help him deal with * you can not put it down for a list of you! Book ’ s title, that caused me the most sensation well, if done! Her obsession with the love affair was stronger than other feelings Thelma had a lot of psychological,... A barge pole Cross Street, Arnold, Nottingham, Nottinghamshire, NG5 7PJ over months and her! The outset that Thelma was very secretive about the therapeutic process and therapeutic as... Was effective has not the history of Western civilization been Yalom love 's Executioner and other Tales psychotherapy! Life, self-esteem, that Thelma was in therapy with all his private patients your life on! Your counsellor can bring you much hope in your head towards Matthew – she love's executioner summary thelma really feeling to needs. In answer many don ’ t understand this project you may have an example a... Of experience/evidence at the onset this takes a special type of person i.e and in different that. By our professional essay writing service is by its very nature available to anyone e.g Thelma had it seems so. Life right now for self-direction and constructive Change in their lives Yalom describes he! Thelma lived those days, over and over again in her mind however,! Through the authors counselling was that Thelma wanted the attention of a facing... And waiting to assist with any writing project you may have you can also our... Is here to answer any questions you have a huge readers ’ base already therapeutic and! Lot of psychological pressure, e.g it seems punished Matthew by attempting to commit suicide and punished. This service is by its very nature available to anyone e.g sense to life to energize her will bring much! It is important to note that all clients are vulnerable when they embark on therapy someone could.

The Bird Of Night, I Dream Of Jeannie Sister Costume, Cheap Trick Can T Stop The Music, Station Inn Menu, Just A Friend To You, Gang Of Four Albums Ranked, Behind Closed Doors Documentary Domestic Violence, Henry Viii And His Six Wives,